Orange County DA Files New Legal Challenge to Block Newsom’s Mass Death Row Commutations
Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer has filed another legal challenge against California Governor Gavin Newsom’s decision to commute the death sentences of all 548 inmates on the state’s death row, accusing the Democratic governor of disregarding the will of California voters.
Spitzer filed an emergency petition with the California Supreme Court on Friday, seeking to immediately block the commutations of 18 condemned inmates convicted in Orange County.
The filing marks Spitzer’s second legal challenge in one week against Newsom’s sweeping decision to replace death sentences with life imprisonment without the possibility of parole.
Newsom announced the mass commutations on November 5, arguing that capital punishment is incompatible with California’s values and justice system.
Spitzer maintains that the governor exceeded his constitutional authority by issuing blanket commutations without reviewing the circumstances of each individual case.
The latest challenge specifically targets 18 inmates whose commutations do not require California Supreme Court approval because they lack prior felony convictions. The court has ordered the state’s solicitor general to respond to Spitzer’s arguments within 10 days.
Earlier in the week, Spitzer filed a separate brief challenging the commutations of 382 death row inmates with previous felony convictions. Under California law, those commutations require approval from a majority of the state’s Supreme Court justices.
Spitzer emphasized that California voters have repeatedly rejected ballot measures seeking to abolish the death penalty and replace existing death sentences with life imprisonment.
Among the condemned inmates affected by the latest filing are Alejandro Avila, convicted of murdering five-year-old Samantha Runnion, and Daniel Patrick Wozniak, convicted of killing two people in a scheme to steal money and conceal his crimes.
The district attorney argued that Newsom’s decision disregards the verdicts reached by juries and the legal process that upheld the death sentences.
Spitzer also accused Newsom of allowing his political ambitions to influence the decision, suggesting that the governor’s opposition to capital punishment could appeal to Democratic voters ahead of a potential 2028 presidential campaign.
Newsom has defended his decision on moral and legal grounds, maintaining that California’s death penalty system is costly, unfair, and incompatible with his beliefs about justice.
California has not carried out an execution since 2006, and Newsom previously imposed a moratorium on executions in 2019.
The latest court challenge could determine whether Newsom’s commutations can proceed without individualized consideration of the inmates’ crimes and sentences.
Spitzer has vowed to continue challenging the governor’s actions as the legal dispute moves through California’s highest court.
