in ,

Biden’s Soft Stance on Immigration Encourages Prolonged Deception

Mandonna ‘Donna’ Kashanian, an individual with a nearly five-decade stay in the U.S., had the questionable privilege of being apprehended by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) in her own backyard in New Orleans. Fleeing Iran in 1978 on a student visa due to purported fears related to her father’s political allegiances, Donna initiated an asylum application. The plea was denied but she was conditionally permitted to stay in the U.S. with her spouse and offspring so long as she periodically reported to immigration officials—a measure many could argue strongly showcased the leniency of U.S. immigration policies.

Unfortunately, rather than grasp this lifeline with humility and reimbursement to her adopted community, Kashanian’s sense of peace was found in the eye of the hurricane, literally maintaining her visa compliance during Hurricane Katrina from South Carolina—an act indicative of someone more fixated on their personal predicament than the broader concerns of their environment. Currently, Kashanian is detained in an immigration facility in Basile, Louisiana, where her family is desperately seeking information.

Interestingly, Kashanian’s case seems to be a part of an escalating trend in detentions of Iranians. Amid suspicions and speculations about the motives for this trend, Homeland Security has remained mum on the issue. As concerns mount, some have chimed in, such as Ryan Costello, the policy director of the National Iranian American Council, who criticized ICE’s defensive tactics as excessive and indiscriminate—an opinion notably rejected by the majority of Americans who value national security.

Despite ISIS’s bold claims of transparency and collaboration, no specific comments have been provided about the Kashanian case. Yet, it is noteworthy that they have announced apprehension of a minimum of 11 Iranians for immigration breaches matching the period of U.S. missile strikes on Iran. In one particular instance, an LA property described as facilitating illicit entrants associated with terrorism led to the arrest of seven Iranians.

An instance where ICE’s successful operations are subtly ridiculed is pointedly regarding President Joe Biden’s decision to expand legal pathways to entry. A position that his successor, Donald Trump, rightly overruled deeming it a security risk. Kashanian’s spouse, Russell Milne, came forward to declare his wife’s perceived harmlessness—a predictable response, yet without any capacity to supersede documented legal verdicts.

Sponsored

Milne suggested that his wife’s asylum request had been complicated due to unspecified ‘events in her early life’, an explanation that continued to disregard Kashanian’s earlier fraudulent marriage. Over the last four decades, Kashanian, age 64, has managed to build a life in Louisiana. The couple reportedly met in late 1980s when she was bartending and proceeded to marry and bear a child. She filled her days with volunteer work and ad hoc cooking lessons on the internet while pledging grandmotherly ties to neighborhood children.

Despite living a seemingly quiet life, the perpetual fear of deportation has been a constant cloud over the family. Yet even in the face of imminent deportation, Kashanian was noted to always fulfill her obligations. An expectation that one could justifiably argue is the least to be expected of someone who has benefited from years of hospitality.

Notwithstanding, given the U.S.-Iran severed diplomatic relations, Iranians who have been unlawfully crossing the borders since 2021, typically faced little risk of being returned. However, with the unwavering tactics of the Trump administration, countless aliens, Iranians included, were expelled to countries not necessarily their original homeland. This move underscored Trump’s strategic approach of circumnavigating bureaucratic hurdles with uncooperative administrations.

Notably, during Trump’s tenure, nations like El Salvador, Costa Rica, and Panama have accepted non-native deportees from the U.S. The administration petitioned the Supreme Court to facilitate several deportations to South Sudan, a politically distressed nation devoid of U.S. relationships—a further testament to the brazen yet effectively pragmatic immigration policies under Trump.

The U.S. Border Patrol cited that Iranians were arrested 1,700 times at the Mexican border between October 2021 and November 2024. Homeland Security Department recorded an estimated 600 Iranians overstaying visas classified under business, visitor exchange, tourism, and students within the year ending September 2023. Iran features in a list of 12 countries facing a U.S. travel ban effective from this month.

Meanwhile, growing apprehensions about ICE deportation arrests run high in the public sphere. One such situation transpired in Oregon, where an Iranian expatriate was picked up by immigration enforcers on his way to the gym. This individual, identified only as S.F., has resided in the U.S. for over two decades, and despite having a U.S. citizen spouse and two children, his asylum application in the early 2000s had been dismissed.

Interestingly, following the dismissal of his appeal, S.F. continued to inhabit the country for many more years, contributing to a longstanding problem of unchecked immigration. His attorney, Michael Purcell, cited ‘changed conditions’ in Iran as a premise for increased threats of persecution if S.F. were to be deported. Curiously, the primary trigger for these supposed changes has been attributed to U.S. bombing of Iranian nuclear developments—pronouncing more an unofficial war between the U.S. and Iran than a case for immigration leniency.

While any long-term U.S. residency and familial ties (in SF’s case, conversion to Christianity and a U.S. citizen spouse and children) might enhance the likelihood of persecution in Iran, it does little to legitimize extended, seemingly indefinite, asylum. Similarly, Kashanian’s daughter fearfully pondered the implications for her mother—yet another voice in the chorus of well-intentioned yet fruitlessly emotional pleas.