Vice President JD Vance is steering clear of political conflict with Pope Leo XIV, responding with measured restraint after the newly elected American-born pontiff criticized aspects of U.S. immigration policy and questioned the moral framing of Trump administration border initiatives.
Pope Leo XIV — formerly Cardinal Robert Prevost — reportedly voiced concerns in the weeks leading up to the conclave about how certain political leaders, including Vance, have invoked Christianity in support of firm immigration enforcement. The comments drew attention after Leo XIV was elected as the first-ever pope from the United States.
Vance, known for his unapologetic America First stance on border security, declined to escalate the situation. “I try not to play the politicization of the Pope game,” he said in response. “The Church’s role is spiritual leadership. My job is to help run the country.”
Rather than spar with the pontiff, Vance emphasized a shared commitment to faith and a respect for the Church’s sacred mission. He noted that while disagreements on policy are natural, they shouldn’t undermine the unity of the Church or the faithful.
“I respect the Pope’s position and pray for him and his success,” Vance added. “His election is a historic moment — the first American pope. That’s a great thing for Catholics around the world.”
The exchange underscores Vance’s approach to leadership: principled, grounded in faith, and unshaken by criticism. While some expected a sharper political response, the Vice President instead reinforced his priorities—protecting national security, defending the border, and upholding values without using the Church as a political weapon.
By sidestepping the media’s attempt to frame the moment as a theological showdown, Vance signaled that his administration remains focused on results—not rhetorical sparring.